Quick Broken Arrow OK MLS Search

Browse All Broken Arrow OK Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

$415,000
5 Beds 3 Baths 2615980 MLS
Modern Luxury Meets Timeless Craftsman Elegance in The Reserve Extensively remodeled and thoughtfully reimagined, this exceptional Traditional Craftsman residence in the prestigious gated community of The Reserve offers the perfect blend of timeless architecture and today's modern design. The current owners have invested in a remarkable interior transformation, creating a home that is truly move-in ready while preserving its original character and craftsmanship. The renovation includes the complete removal of all wallpaper throughout the home, professionally resurfaced and repaired walls, and fresh designer-selected paint throughout the entire interior, creating a light, bright, and contemporary aesthetic. New carpet in the bedrooms and office further enhances the home's fresh, luxurious feel. Designed with both everyday living and entertaining in mind, the open-concept floor plan showcases soaring ceilings, abundant natural light, rich architectural details, and spacious living areas. The flexible layout offers 5 true bedrooms or 4 bedrooms with a private executive office, allowing buyers to customize the space to fit their lifestyle. Upstairs, the expansive bonus room is ideal as a media room, game room, home theater, fitness studio, or playroom. The spacious primary suite is a private retreat featuring a spa-inspired ensuite bath and an oversized walk-in closet. Additional recent improvements include a roof replaced within the past five years, a hot water heater replaced within the last year, two new toilets, security system wiring, and numerous cosmetic updates throughout the home. A standout feature is the climate-controlled three-car garage with dedicated heating and air conditioning—perfect for a workshop, home gym, hobby space, or premium storage. Residents of The Reserve enjoy gated security and exceptional neighborhood amenities, including a resort-style pool, playground, scenic walking trails, and a stocked fishing pond.

4213 S Palm Avenue, Broken Arrow

$438,340
4 Beds 3 Baths 2617139 MLS
2909 E Northampton St is home to the Hummingbird Bonus Room 1 floor plan. Four bedrooms, three bathrooms, a utility room, and a large bonus room add up to 2,250 Sq Ft (per BP) of clever interior living. This Proudly Overbuilt home also welcomes covered patios so you can enjoy the outdoors along with a three-car garage featuring a tankless water heater and an in-ground storm shelter. The great room extends from the front entrance to the back of the house, embracing high ceilings and our preferred wood-look tile. Here, you will enjoy a stacked stone gas fireplace, large windows, rocker switches throughout, Cat6 wiring, and a marvelous cathedral ceiling featuring a cathedral chandelier. The upscale kitchen is a skip away and showcases our beautiful custom-built cabinets to the ceiling with cabinet hardware, stainless steel appliances, modern tile backsplash, exclusive pendant lighting, 3 CM countertops, a walk-in pantry, and a large kitchen island with a trash can pullout. Your primary suite is situated towards the front of the home, debuting the unique layout featured in the Hummingbird family. This suite presents a sloped ceiling detail with a ceiling fan, carpeted flooring, Cat6 wiring, and the perfect sized windows. The primary bath supports a dual sink vanity with framed mirrors, a private water closet, a free-standing tub, a European walk-in shower, tile flooring, and not one but two walk-in closets. The possibilities are endless with our Proudly Overbuilt floor plans. That is why this Red Series home includes our healthy home technology, a whole home air filtration system, a tankless heater, double glazed vinyl low E windows with argon, R-15 & R-44 insulation, and so much MORE!

2909 E Northampton Street, Broken Arrow

$451,140
4 Beds 3 Baths 2617273 MLS
2820 E Northampton St is home to the Blue Spruce Bonus Room 1 floor plan. The Blue Spruce welcomes distinctive lines of great curb appeal that extend throughout the interior. Four Bedrooms define the home, 3 full Bathrooms complement the home, and a large bonus room completes this elegant floor plan. A large fireplace featuring a stacked stone detail to the ceiling sits at the end of your living room, adding a natural focal point to this vast area. We have also integrated an outstanding cathedral ceiling with a ceiling fan, large windows, rocker switches installed throughout, Cat6 wiring, and prime wood look tile to make this build true real estate heaven. Thoughtful construction and design went into the establishment of this high-end kitchen. Designed for convenience, efficiency, and style, we have proudly included well-crafted cabinets to the ceiling with under cabinet lighting and cabinet hardware installed throughout, stainless steel appliances, a 5-burner cooktop, elegant tile backsplash, 3 CM countertops, exceptional pendant lighting, an oversized center island equipped with a trash can pullout, and a separate walk-in pantry for ample storage. Situated at the rear of the house is the primary suite. Here, you will find a sloped ceiling detail with a ceiling fan, promising windows, and our soothing carpet finish. For further relaxation, step into your spa-like primary bath which provides a free-standing tub, separate vanities with framed mirrors, a European walk-in shower, a private elongated toilet with cabinets above, tile flooring, as well as a glorious walk-in closet that is partitioned to provide a yours and mine distinction. Lastly, enjoy all the amenities featured in a Taber Home. These Proudly Overbuilt amenities include a wood-burning fireplace, a gas line, a TV hookup, a tankless water heater, R-44 insulation, healthy home technology, and so much more!

2820 E Northampton Street, Broken Arrow

$498,140
4 Beds 3 Baths 2617252 MLS
2900 E Northampton St is home to the Mallory Bonus Room. This new build welcomes 4 Bedrooms, 3 full Bathrooms, a mudroom featuring a mud bench, a utility room featuring a utility sink, a spacious bonus room, and a 3-car garage with an in-ground storm shelter installed. This desirable open floor plan maintains the creative design and uniqueness of the original Mallory by boasting our preferred wood-look tile and 10' ceilings. The great room welcomes a 3-panel sliding door with a 4' back patio extension, a corner gas fireplace surrounded by a stacked stone detail to the ceiling, rocker switches throughout, Cat6 wiring, a ceiling fan, and an extraordinary coffered ceiling that extends from your living room to your dining room. Create your favorite meals in this upscale kitchen, which features stainless steel appliances, a 5-burner cooktop, double ovens, custom-built cabinets to the ceiling, decorative tile backsplash, exclusive pendant lighting, 3 CM countertops, a corner pantry, and a center island with a trash can pullout. This suite has been slightly expanded from the original design, yet maintains all the exceptional qualities you know and love. Here, you will enjoy a sloped ceiling detail, a ceiling fan, windows, Cat6 wiring, and our carpeted flooring. The well-designed bath supports a dual sink vanity with framed mirrors, a free-standing tub, a private water closet, a walk-in shower, and a large walk-in closet. Other amenities to enjoy in this Proudly Overbuilt home include a wood-burning fireplace, a gas line, a TV hookup, a tankless water heater, R-44 insulation, and so much more!

2900 E Northampton Street, Broken Arrow

$443,190
4 Beds 3 Baths 2617159 MLS
This 4 Bed, 3 Bath home in Broken Arrow is located at 2904 E Northampton St. The Sage Bonus Room 1 floor plan is a top-tier plan that boasts four bedrooms, three bathrooms, a utility room, a bonus room, covered patios, and a three-car garage complete with a hand-picked in-ground storm shelter and the beloved tankless water heater. Your new home guarantees stunning views with Proudly Overbuilt features that set this builder apart from the others. This great room presents a cathedral ceiling with a ceiling fan, rocker switches throughout, large windows, wood-look tile flooring, Cat6 wiring, and a gas fireplace detailed with our stacked stone design. Your new kitchen features custom-built cabinets to the ceiling with glass and lights in the uppers, 3 CM countertops, exclusive pendant lighting, a large kitchen island, stainless steel appliances, modern tile backsplash, a 5-burner cooktop, and a spacious corner pantry featuring a glass pantry door. Just beyond this area lies your grandiose primary suite. This area offers ample space to unwind, featuring an elegant sloped ceiling detail, large windows, and an exquisite carpet finish. Your primary bath adds the comfort of a free-standing tub, a walk-in shower, a dual sink vanity, a private water closet, tile flooring, and an exceptional walk-in closet. End your day on your covered back patio, where you can relax and enjoy the fresh air and great views. This builder offers a wood-burning fireplace, a gas line connection for your grill, and a TV hookup so you can watch your favorite shows while enjoying Oklahoma's water-colored skies.

2904 E Northampton Street, Broken Arrow

$464,090
4 Beds 3 Baths 2617046 MLS
Stunning 4 Bed, 3 Bath new build home in Broken Arrow’s, Whiskey Ridge neighborhood. The outstanding interior of the Shiloh Bonus Room maintains the classic lines of its namesake, but add a bonus room and see why this plan ranks supreme. The Shiloh Bonus Room is a timeless classic that everyone knows and loves. 2,450 Sq Ft (BP) adds up to an impeccable interior while 355 Sq Ft (BP) creates a luxurious outdoor atmosphere. Within these walls, you will enjoy 4 large bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, a bonus room, a utility room featuring a utility sink, and a 3-car garage with an in-ground storm shelter. Your entertainment zone is loaded with Proudly Overbuilt features that contribute to this builder being Oklahoma's Favorite Builder. The great room welcomes a coffered ceiling with a ceiling fan, crown molding, wood-look tile flooring, rocker switches throughout, 7' windows, a gas fireplace surrounded by a stacked stone detail, and Cat6 wiring. The exuberant kitchen supports custom-built cabinets to the ceiling, a kitchen island equipped with a trash can pullout, stainless steel appliances, a 5-burner cooktop, 3 CM countertops, upgraded kitchen backsplash, exclusive pendant lighting, and a large corner pantry. Find pure relaxation and solace in your primary suite. Here, you will enjoy large windows, carpeted flooring, a ceiling fan, a sloped ceiling detail, and two primary walk-in closets. The spa-like primary bath boasts separate sink vanities with framed mirrors, 3 CM countertops, tile flooring, a European walk-in shower, a private water closet, and a free-standing tub. Enjoy the outdoors by taking advantage of your wood-burning fireplace, gas line, and TV hookup that's all included! We also include energy-efficient appliances to enhance your living standard. Such instruments include a tankless water heater, a whole home air filtration system, our healthy home technology, and so much more!

2912 E Northampton Street, Broken Arrow

$488,000
5 Beds 4 Baths 2617127 MLS
Experience exceptional living in this stunning custom-built home situated in the highly sought-after Greens at Cedar Ridge. Meticulously maintained, this immaculate one-owner home rests on a large 0.27-acre lot and features a convenient side-entry three-car garage. The full brick exterior, complemented by a newer roof, ensures durability and timeless curb appeal. Inside, discover elegant hardwood flooring throughout the first floor and exquisite custom details and finishes. The inviting family room boasts a soaring sixteen-foot ceiling, built-in bookcases, and a cozy gas log fireplace, creating the perfect ambiance for relaxation and gatherings. Culinary enthusiasts will love the designer kitchen equipped with custom cabinetry, granite countertops, double ovens, a built-in refrigerator, island seating, and a cozy breakfast nook. A generously sized primary suite on the first floor offers wood flooring and a spa-like bath complete with a double sink vanity, jetted tub, separate shower, and a spacious walk-in closet. Additional first-floor accommodations include the spacious 2nd and 3rd bedrooms, a full bath and a convenient half bath, while the second floor houses a fourth and fifth bedroom— the latter ideal as a game or media room—plus a full bathroom. Step outside to a covered patio perfect for entertaining and enjoy the beautifully landscaped, fully fenced backyard. Additional features include a whole-home generator and an interior safe room storm shelter for peace of mind. Wonderful community, Nearby Cedar Ridge Country Club offers a championship golf course, swimming pool, tennis and pickleball courts, fitness center, and fine dining. This prime location offers easy access to Tulsa’s premier shopping, dining, and highways.

3920 S Sequoia Avenue, Broken Arrow

$440,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 2616007 MLS
15 solar panels included helping almost free electricity. Full bricks house provide excellent thermal insulation. Year Build 2021 everything same like brand new. Granite countertops all of kitchen. Super comfortable 4 bed, 2 and half bath, 3 car garage home on .19 acre in Broken Arrow Stone Horse Subdivision. This home offers beautiful titles surface flooring and carpet in bedrooms , lots of natural light, a kitchen with pantry, stainless appliances, granite counter tops .The spacious, bright kitchen and dining nook open into a giant living area with 10-foot ceilings. Primary bedroom is roomy with lots of furnishing options, private bath has tub/shower combo and opens to large walk-in closet. Neighborhood offers sidewalks, park and pool! Built to Full Energy Star Standards: ENERGY STAR Certified home allows you to live more comfortably, invest your housing dollars more wisely and it helps the environment - all of which can make your Energy Star Certified home easier to resell. It's what we call a "win-win-win!" . ENERGY STAR Certified Home, saving up to 30 percent on heating and cooling costs , make it easy and affordable to own the home of your dreams. Home is built to the highest standard, with architectural innovation, tremendous quality. This Beckett plan is designed to maximize value and livability. This Homes are some of the most highly energy efficient homes in the Tulsa metro in this price range, saving you thousands of dollars annually on home heating and cooling costs.

3109 W Winston Street, Broken Arrow

$434,796
4 Beds 3 Baths 2610868 MLS
The Hartford offers a spacious single-level layout thoughtfully designed for comfort, privacy, and personalization. The split floor plan effortlessly balances connection and seclusion, positioning the generous primary suite — complete with a beautifully appointed bathroom featuring a soaking tub, separate walk-in shower, and walk-in closets — away from the secondary bedrooms. The main living area brings together an open kitchen with quartz countertops, a farmhouse sink, and a stacked wall oven and microwave, flowing seamlessly into a breakfast nook and a warm family room anchored by a beautiful fireplace. A formal dining room adds versatility for hosting gatherings or creating a dedicated celebration space, while a convenient locker cabinet keeps everyday essentials organized. The secondary bedrooms are thoughtfully grouped with easy access to shared bathrooms, making the layout as functional as it is inviting. With a wide range of configuration options, The Hartford is designed to adapt gracefully to a variety of lifestyles and personal preferences — whether you’re hosting guests, growing a family, or simply enjoying the ease of single-level living. Home Highlights Open kitchen, breakfast nook, and family room Formal dining room for added flexibility Split floor plan for privacy and function Primary suite with walk-in closets The Primary Suite has a freestanding ceramic tub and a separate walk-in shower. Standard 3-car garage

5010 N Walnut Avenue, Broken Arrow

$440,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 2545942 MLS
Before you miss the opportunity to call Timberbrook home, discover this beautifully maintained one-level stone home offering space, comfort, and exceptional accessibility on approximately one acre cul-de-sac that backs to a greenbelt. Designed with accessibility in mind, this home offers level entry from the driveway through the garage or out patio to backyard, wide hallways, and 36-inch doors for 2 bedrooms and 2 baths for easier mobility. Bathrooms can accommodate a wheelchair, roll-in shower, lift or step in shower. These ADA-friendly features make the home comfortable and functional without sacrificing style. This versatile 3-bedroom, 3-bath home welcomes you with an expansive living and dining area highlighted by four skylights, while the inviting family room features a cozy corner fireplace. The remodeled kitchen boasts Corian countertops, abundant workspace, and a sunny breakfast nook. A thoughtfully designed interior addition created a private third-bedroom suite with its own living area and covered back porch, making it ideal for guests, multi-generational living, or a private retreat. The finished, climate-controlled sunroom has been insulated, wood paneling, and equipped with a mini-split system for year-round enjoyment. Additional highlights include zoned heating and air, a central vacuum system, whole house surge protectors, 2 hot water heaters, fully insulated garage with work space and energy-efficient insulated windows. Outside, you'll find an inground pool complete with sweeper, cover, and handrail, along with a fully fenced and cross-fenced yard. Hobbyists and outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate the approximately 24' x 17' workshop, 14' x 12' storage shed. This one-of-a-kind property offers the perfect combination of accessibility, functionality, and outdoor living in a peaceful neighborhood setting. Schedule your showing today.

21780 E 66th Circle S, Broken Arrow

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data exchange (“IDX”) program of Greater Tulsa Association of Realtors. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright© 2026 Greater Tulsa Association of Realtors. All Rights Reserved. Last Updated: .

Between $400K - $500K Broken Arrow Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $400k - $500k properties available in Broken Arrow and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!